Apr 22, 2014

Why do Stormtroopers 'always' miss their targets?

Why do Stormtroopers 'always' miss their targets?

It's become a bit of a joke on the internet that Stormtroopers always miss their target.

Storm Troopers are so bad at firing their weaponry that the heroes always get away with not even a scratch.

There's even a popular joke that if a Stormtrooper shoots a Star Trek 'red shirt' the red shirt will still die. Which may say more about Star Trek...

But do Stormtroopers really miss? The evidence suggests otherwise and that it's a myth they always miss.

Let's start with A New Hope.

The opening scene involves Stormtroopers boarding Princess Leia's ship, the Tantive IV. The entry hatch is blasted and out swarm the troopers into their own kill box they just created. They then proceed to kill most of the men aboard the vessel using their.... blasters. They basically shot their way out of a hole in the wall.

They were deadly accurate and  later on one of them was even able to quickly switch to stun and take down Princess Leia herself. Mission accomplished boys.

Whilst on Tattoine, Luke and Obiwan come across the Jawa's barge which has been shot to shit by Storm Troopers. Luke surmises it was the Tusken Raiders but Obi Wan is moved to note that "these blast points, too accurate for sand people. Only imperial storm troopers are so precise."

Now lets bear in mind that Obi Wan Kenobi is not merely a craxy old hermit, he was a General who fought in the Clone Wars. He knows what he is talking about. And as we later found out from the Clone Wars / Sith movie, we know he survived Order 66 - we'll talk about that some more later.

Also remember that Aunt Beru and Uncle Own were turned into crispy critters.

A few scenes later and we are on board the Death Star. Which is where all the talk of Stormtroopers missing appears to stem from. Queue the prison cell block break out.

Our heroes are pinned down in a corridor with cloned marksmen shooting at them with some serious firepower and they all miss. Yep. You got us there.

Our heroes are then later attempting to sneak onboard the Millennium Falcon as Obi Wan becomes one with the Force at the hands of Vader to wit Luke cries out Noooooooooo (like father, like son eh?).

The distracted troopers note the escape and commence firing at our heroes. All shots miss. Yep, you got us there. These Storm Troopers can't hit the side of a barn.

But hold the phone, don't we find out after our heroes escape that Governor Tarkin had ordered a homing beacon placed on the Falcon in an attempt to learn the location of the rebel forces? He was pretty serious about finding them, you'll recall he blew up Alderaan to try and get the location from Princess Leia.

So if it was that important for Tarkin to learn the location of the rebels secret base do you think he would allow the Stormtroopers to actually harm our heroes? The reality is Tarkin actually let them escape so our heroes would inadvertently lead him to the rebel fleet.
This means the Stormtroopers were deliberately missing their supposed targets.
You might be asking yourself, but because of their inability to shoot to kill, the Clone soldiers were dying at the hands of our heroes.

Yes, yes they were and the sequels revealed the Clones were under the direct control of the Republic and by the time A New Hope rolled around, under Lord Sidous. They were at his beck and call to do his will. And by delegated authority, they were Tarkin's minions. So when he orders them to not kill, that's all they do.

The Empire Strikes Back has more examples

Not enough for you? Let's consider The Empire Strikes Back, in particular the time spent at Cloud City.

The whole damn exercise is a trap set by Vader to capture Luke Skywalker and turn him to the Dark Side (side note, Leia says the original 'it's a trap' line to Luke!).

So when Leia and Han are running around avoiding being shot - well it's all moot as Vader has ordered the Falcon's hyper drive to be disabled. A deliberate 'no escape' ploy by Vader. Because if they escape, Luke will not turn up. If they are dead, Luke will sense this and still not turn up.

Plan B is to freeze Han Solo in carbonite so why kill him? Either way, the idea is to lure Luke. Heck, Han's torture was only intended to make sure Luke felt his friend's pain and make sure he turned up to play his part.

The a priori deduction behind all this is again the  stormtroopers have been ordered not to shoot and kill our heroes. So they are deliberately missing. 

Is this not enough? Are you not entertained by this notion? Okay it's a lot more loose than the argument found in ANH. Let's get to Jedi but we are going to have to talk about Ewoks. I love the little fuzzballs but a lot of you hate the critters. Bear with me.

Return of the Jedi

Let's offer this premise. Luke Skywalker is about to become a truly great Jedi. Han Solo is one of the best smugglers in the galaxy and perhaps one of the bravest men around. Leia knows a thing or two about warfare and Chewbacca survived the battle on Kashyyyk and is actually one of the most bad ass creatures in the Galaxy.

R2D2 is one of the most awesome astro mechs in the history of robots. C3PO is merely along for the ride.... AND yet, these great players managed to get themselves caught by the Ewok in a very simple trap thanks to Chewie thinking with his stomach.

Bear that in mind when we talk about the Battle of Endor. Yes the stormtroopers ultimately lose to the furballs but they sure managed to kill a lot of them. They were not missing their shots that day!

Leia was also shot. I'll let it slide that it was perhaps a stray shot but none the less one of our heroes was shot by a laser blast from a Stormtrooper. Yeah, this line of thought is loose as.

What about those sharp shooters that killed everyone and everything in the Prequel Films?

You could argue that the Storm Troopers in the original trilogy were starting to show their age I guess...perhaps they were in need of some eye glasses.

So that covers the original trilogy. I've argued that the joke about Storm Troopers being unable to hit the side of a barn is just that, a joke. Attack of the Clones revealed that the troopers were simply clones of Jango Fett, a player that was no slug with weaponry (well, till he took a blaster to a sword fight with Mace Windu).

These Clones were the business and who saved the day at the end of the film? Yoda and his Clone Army that was all Stormtrooper baby!

So much so that when it was time for Order 66 in Revenge of the Sith, the true value and skill of the Storm Troopers was realised. Order 66 was an imprinted command on the troops to kill the Jedi they were with when the order was received and the Sith film showed the soldiers shooting down many a Jedi warrior. Albeit they weren't fair fights, none the less the troopers blasts were very precise.

You might go, hang on minute, Obi Wan and Yoda survived Order 66 so the Troopers still suck.

es, it's very true they did survive but how many Jedi died at the hands of Storm troopers who were fighting battles in the midst of the clone Wars ? 10,000 but who is counting - heck this is a discourse on how good a shot a storm trooper actually is, not about their abilities to kill Jedi or two of the greatest Jedi ever.

At the end of the day, Star Wars is a set of movies and film making is not a perfect art. Some things just are the way they are because the writer wrote things a certain way. Who expected Star Wars to come under so much scrutiny?

Anyways, none of  this explains why Chewbacca didn't get a medal at the end of A New Hope...


Clone Wars vet Dave Filoni offered his own thoughts when doing some promo for Star Wars: Rebels

"When Obi Wan says, ‘Only Imperial Stormtroopers are so precise’, I think he’s making that up on the fact that he used to fight with clones, so he assumes that a Stormtrooper is really good. Much to his shock those guys can’t hit an R2 unit in a naked hallway, let alone be precise. So I like Stormtroopers, I find them very interesting. The Stormtroopers have better gear, better weapons in a lot of ways but it’s just a different war they are fighting than the Clone troopers’ was."

A most interesting take!


  1. Just a quick comment, supposedly by the time of A New Hope, the Empire no longer uses clones as stormtroopers, and is instead a regular army which recruits, that are trained by the veteran clones... check the wookiepedia :D

    1. I was thinking the same thing everytime I saw "clone". Due to their accelerated aging (2 times as fast, if I remember right) there were not enough clones remaining to make up the Imperial military, forcing the Empire to begin accepting humans instead, since the Emperor was a specicist

  2. I would think the easiest reason they would miss would be not to get promoted. You have seen what happens to people who get into top management. It seems like a slaughterhouse.

  3. The thing not mentioned is that it is a movie and what movie would let it's heroes die half way through the first movie if they plan on making more and I know episode 7 but he didn't affect the plot too much by that point